The Grabber returns in Scott Derrickson’s sequel to his 2021 horror film. Here’s our Black Phone 2 review. Warning! This review contains spoilers for The Black Phone, particularly its ending. Director and co-writer Scott Derrickson’s The Black Phone was a bit of a surprise hit. The Ethan Hawke-starring horror thriller grossed over $161m at the ... Black Phone 2 review | Sweet dreams aren’t made of this
The Grabber returns in Scott Derrickson’s sequel to his 2021 horror film. Here’s our Black Phone 2 review.
Warning! This review contains spoilers for The Black Phone, particularly its ending.
Director and co-writer Scott Derrickson’s The Black Phone was a bit of a surprise hit. The Ethan Hawke-starring horror thriller grossed over $161m at the global box office, far more than expected. It was a perfectly decent film, too, even if this writer found it a little lacking in the original idea department.
Can the sequel do better?
Black Phone 2 brings back Mason Thames as the now-traumatised teenager Finney, and Madeline McGraw as his psychic sister, Gwen. Gwen’s visions are getting stronger, and now she’s dreaming of the Grabber’s previous victims, trapped under the ice at a lake where the pair’s mother used to work as a camp counsellor.
Much like its predecessor, Black Phone 2 isn’t particularly interested in offering anything new with its twists and turns. The second film leans even more heavily to its inspirations, borrowing more than a little from Wes Craven’s A Nightmare On Elm Street and its multiple sequels. One could even accuse it of leaning a bit too hard on that classic.

The Grabber is now trapped in icy hell, but he still has a bone to pick with Finney and Gwen, and somehow has the ability to appear in their dreams. Much like Freddy Krueger, the Grabber can cause damage in the real world by hurting his victims as they sleep – and boy is he looking to cause some damage.
To his credit, Derrickson puts a lot of effort into crafting an oppressive atmosphere at the beginning. There’s genuine tension, and although Craven’s sleepy horror franchise is clearly the inspiration here, the dream scenarios work well. There’s also a delightful amount of gore, showcasing a willingness to push at least some boundaries and an attempt to truly shock the audience rather than mildly chill them.
These are undermined by an over-fondness of jump scares and dialogue that’s either meant to be funny and purposefully cringey or simply sounds that way by accident. It’s almost like Derrickson suddenly decided that the recipe for a successful, effective horror film demands mechanically inserted, empty jump scares that are only designed to make you spill your overpriced drink on your lap rather than truly frighten you.
As the film moves on, the scares become more and more frequent, but that oppressive atmosphere gradually ebbs. Black Phone 2 is at its best when Derrickson and co-writer Robert C Cargill trust their audience and the story itself to provide thrills outside of the traditional scares.
Thankfully, Derrickson keeps things moving at a decent pace. The film comes in at just under two hours, which means it doesn’t overstay its welcome. Black Phone 2 offers much more Ethan Hawke as The Grabber compared to the first film. Derrickson clearly learned his lesson, and Hawke is having a great time snarling his lines at the young cast.
Speaking of the young cast, things aren’t as rosy for them as they are for Hawke. The first film was largely told from Finney’s perspective, with his sister’s psychic abilities also playing a big supporting part, but the sequel switches the focus to Gwen. Finney, while still in the picture, is largely left undeveloped, as is Miguel Mora’s Ernesto, who mostly disappears somewhere around the halfway mark.
Still, Black Phone 2 just about scrapes the line of a decent horror movie, mostly thanks to Hawke’s deranged performance and an early focus on building a haunting atmosphere.
Black Phone 2 is in UK cinemas 17th October.



